Okay, my run at it ... and I will try and limit me editing to only 2 or 3 times, though like Jimmy, I am sure I will want to tweek the hell out of this.
1- Captain America: The Winter Soldier
2- The Avengers
3- Iron Man
4- Captain America: The First Avenger
6- Iron Man 2
7- Thor: Dark World
9- X-Men: First Class
11- Spider-Man 2
13- Amazing Spider-Man
14- Iron Man 3
15- Incredible Hulk
17- Blade 2
18- X-Men Origins: Wolverine
19- Daredevil (Yes, the directors cut)
20- The Wolverine
22- Spider-Man 3
23- X-Men: The Last Stand
24- Fantastic Four
25- Fantastic Four: Rise of the Surfer
26- Blade: Trinity
27- Ghost Rider
29- Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance
31 -The Punisher
32- Punisher: War Zone
A couple notes -
I totally get why Jimmy has Avengers at the top. Great flick and has that "I can't believe they got all these damn heroes together and are making this movie F'n work" feel. It is not scared about being a freaking' super-hero movie and embraces itslef as being one. I just liked Cap WS better as a movie, even though the spectacle that is Avengers will always be towards the top for me.
As I stated in another thread, I never saw Punisher: War Zone, so that has to go last, while the other Punisher and that Man-Thing are "films" that I just couldn't sit through. I was able to laugh more at the Man-Thing, so it gets a little more praise.
Bottom line for me ... the first 11 are really stand-outs to me, the bottom 11 are all pretty much horrid to me, while the middle 10 are pretty adjustable up and down a few spots depending on my mood. I guess, collectively, I would list them in groups:
1-5 = Outstanding films the I truly love
6-11 = Great films films that really respect
12-21 = Really cool, lazy Saturday viewings. Watch no matter how many times I have seen them
22-32 = Really bad, I'd rather do yard work on Saturday than to sit through these damn things
Also really saddened to see FF so high up on Jimmy's list. As an avid FF fan, I just cringe at both those FF movies. An utter travesty what the did with Reed, Sue and of course, Dr. Doom ... or in this film, Dr. Disapproval. But of course, in the grand scheme of things, he only has that movie 12 spots higher than I do.
Here's hoping that the next 3 flicks coming out this year will push us to knock some films out of our top 10!!!!!!